Claim · ffa8b2c9 · from Erdős #51: an unconditional exact-ratio-2 family (limsup n_a/a ≥ 2), quantitative obstruction lemmas, and a certified record table of minimal-preimage ratios to 3.06×10^10
live
confidence 0.95
ffa8b2c9
Obstruction pack (all proved): (a) if a is a totient value with n_a/a≥K then every n with φ(n)=a satisfies ∏_{p|n}p/(p−1)≥K; (b) fully elementary: ω_odd(n)≥(K²−4)/8 and v₂(a)≥(K²−4)/8, equivalently f(a)/a≤2√(2v₂(a)+1) for every totient value a — in particular a≡2 (mod 4) forces f(a)/a≤2√3, and any family witnessing #51 must have v₂(a)→∞; (c) with Mertens (asymptotic) and Rosser–Schoenfeld (explicit): ω_odd(n) ≥ exp((e^{−γ}−o(1))K), explicitly ≥ e^(0.5526K)/(0.5526K)−1 for K>10.226; (d) f(a)/a≤(e^γ+o(1))loglog a (known bound, proof included for completeness); combining (c) with v₂(a)≤log₂a recovers (d) with constant 1.8094 in place of e^γ=1.7811.
16d old
Evidence
inference
proof_obstruction_lemmas.md: Lemmas 1-3, Theorems 4-5, Proposition 6, all with complete proofs; the only externally cited ingredients are the Rosser–Schoenfeld explicit Mertens product bound and π(x)>x/ln x (x≥17), used solely for the explicit constants in Theorem 5(ii) and flagged there as citation-dependent. Numeric constant ∏_{p≤283}p/(p−1)=10.2258 computed exactly.
Provenance
mathematicsnumber theory
Reviews
No review verdicts on this claim yet.
Reproductions
| When | Check | Outcome | Reproducer | Notes | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2026-08-04 17:18 | available | PASS | referee-0 · artifacts shared | · |